The Top 26 Online Jewelry Stores With The Best Quality And Surprisingly Affordable Prices

Looking for the perfect gift for her? These online jewelry stores offer amazing quality and luxury experiences for extremely affordable prices. This is the ultimate list.

Need a gift for her? Have an anniversary coming up? Is it Valentine’s Day soon? Or maybe you’re looking to treat yourself? Beautiful quality jewelry pieces can make the perfect meaningful gift.

Sometimes the best gifts are the ones that are personal. Jewelry is the perfect gift because it is unique to the wearer, and can even be engraved and personalized.

It can be symbolic of people or life milestones. It can serve as talismans of strength and good luck charms, or bring memories of love and joy. Perhaps it even becomes a family heirloom to be passed down to future generations.

Best of all, it’s pretty. And when you wear it, it makes you feel pretty, too.

This post is all about the top 26 online jewelry stores with the best quality and surprisingly affordable prices.

Jewelry can be quite expensive, especially if you’re looking for a quality piece that won’t turn your skin green or tarnish within a week. More and more, online jewelry stores are popping up all over the web, cutting out the middle man, and bringing direct-to-consumer pieces at much lower prices.

^{This post may contain affiliate links, which means I’ll receive a small commission if you purchase through my link, at no extra cost to you. Please read full disclosure here.}

The 26 Best Affordable Online Jewelry Stores

Check out these top sites and you’re bound to find that perfect quality piece that will stay beautiful for years to come.

Mejuri

Mejuri // With limited-edition drops every Monday and tons of influencer collaborations, Mejuri is a favorite go-to stop for handcrafted everyday fine jewelry. Their style leans towards minimalism. Therefore they are the perfect choice for delicate pieces.

Missoma

Missoma // A personal favorite, Missoma has gorgeous bold pieces of fine jewelry that balance the glamorous with the sophisticated. An amazing destination for layering pieces, come to Missoma if you’re looking to curate your own personal jewelry look.

Astrid & Miyu

Astrid & Miyu // If you’re looking for sweet, feminine, and playful earrings for an array of piercings, this site has what you’re looking for. Specializing in curated ear stacks, you can even get your ears pierced at Astrid & Miyu. They also have a beautiful selection of other playful and feminine jewelry to choose from.

Stella & Bow

Stella & Bow // If you’re looking for everyday fine and fashion jewelry, then check out Stella & Bow. They have playful options that typically inject bits of color for subtle charm. Their rainbow pieces feel particularly special.

Aurate

Aurate // If finding ethically sourced, sustainable brands is a priority to you, then you will love Aurate. They have many beautiful gold pieces to check out that are all made of 100% recycled gold and conflict-free diamonds.

VRAI

VRAI // The unique thing about VRAI is that the brand grows their own lab diamonds. If finding an engagement ring is on your to do list, then check out this sustainable brand for some unique and more affordable ring options. They even make designing your own ring affordable.

Local Eclectic

Local Eclectic // In boutique style, Local Eclectic brings together unique and beautiful jewelry finds in one online storefront. They work with artisans and jewelry designers across the globe to make their ethically sourced fine jewelry accessible to consumers. They have quite a large assortment of engagement and wedding rings to choose from.

Tai

Tai // Tai offers affordable, handcrafted jewelry. Styles are so unique and interesting, classic with a twist. There are also beautiful stacking rings to check out on this website.

Daisy London

Daisy London // Next on the list is another online jewelry store that does influencer collaborations. This popular brand is known for its elevated bohemian style jewelry. Come here if you are in search of pieces that are meaningful and at the same time light-hearted.

Wanderlust + Co.

Wanderlust + Co. // Another online jewelry store with a bohemian flair, Wanderlust + Co. has some beautiful celestial inspired gold bits. One of their cult favorites are the tarot necklaces. All jewelry is made by artisans and with sustainable production.

Dixi

Dixi // Nature-inspired bohemian jewelry is Dixi’s specialty. Truly unique and a bit edgy, these pieces are strong statements. A little dark and a bit fantastical, this brand is not for the faint of heart.

Olive + Piper

Olive + Piper // Bridal jewelry and ultra-feminine pieces are signature looks of Olive + Piper. They make truly luxurious looking, traditional, classic, and feminine pieces that any girly girl would cherish.

Brook & York

Brook & York // Classic, American-inspired, and preppy, describe the sophisticated offerings at Brook & York. One of the perks of this online jewelry store? Customized jewelry, like monogrammed pieces and birthstone jewelry.

Ana Luisa

Ana Luisa // At Ana Luisa, jewelry is made of recycled materials whenever possible. It is sustainably made and produced in small batches with environmentally friendly practices in place. Come here when you are looking for more lab-grown diamonds and sustainable, environmentally friendly jewelry bits with innovative designs.

Gorjana

Gorjana // Next, we have Gorjana, a must-see stop for everyday layering jewelry pieces with a timeless style mixed with a touch of bohemian. Engravable gifts and a vast selection are highlights on this site.

Miranda Frye

Miranda Frye // These super-cool and stylish pieces have been seen on celebrities and featured in many editorials for their inspirational designs and quality. Not only that, but they are really affordable. Take a look at Miranda Frye if you are seeking cool and effortless everyday pieces that exude confidence.

Lili Claspe

Lili Claspe // Moody and chic, Lili Claspe’s designs are totally sophisticated and elegant with a touch of tasteful everyday glamour. Two of my favorite pieces are the Reggie Thick necklace and the Reese tennis necklace (featured in the photo below). If you layer these two beauties together then you get a stunning combination that can really elevate your more casual outfits.

Kendra Scott

Kendra Scott // Color, shape, material, and value. These are the pillars of the Kendra Scott brand. Stylish pieces showcasing gorgeous materials in a rainbow of colors can be found on these artistic designs.

Ettika

Ettika // The best way to describe Ettika is timeless with a twist. These pieces can feel nature-inspired while still remaining luxe looking.

Margaret Elizabeth

Margaret Elizabeth // If you’re looking for a playful range of bridal jewelry (for brides and bridal parties) then this store is for you. Not only is the fine jewelry beautiful, but there is also a small selection of vintage pieces to peruse.

Haverhill

Haverhill // Is clean and timeless more your style? Check out Haverhill for eclectic New England-inspired designs.

Monica Vinader

Monica Vinader // Artistically designed luxury pieces is Monica Vinader’s specialty. This brand collaborates with influencers and brings strong collections to anyone looking for a weighted luxurious feel and design.

Stone And Strand

Stone And Strand // If you’re into delicate jewelry then you must come to Stone And Strand where their specialty is amazing dainty jewelry. Their selection of earrings would make for the perfectly delicate curated ear stack. You can even schedule a visit to their Noho studio for ear piercings.

Catbird

Catbird // This Brooklyn-based brand features hip and dainty jewelry. The vibes here are a bit edgy and provide a unique statement, while being 100% cool. They even have somewhat less traditional, but equally beautiful, wedding and engagement rings.

Baublebar

Baublebar // This is one of the original affordable online jewelry stores. They have such an impressive amount of jewelry to choose from that is unparalleled by another brand. You can literally find any jewelry piece you have your heart set on.

Sarah Chloe

Sarah Chloe // Come to Sarah Chloe for the most beautiful and wide selection of personalized jewelry. You can even choose the metal color for more complete customization. The signet rings here are a cult favorite, and a truly special gift for any classy gal.

Jennifer Fisher

Jennifer Fisher // For simple, sculptural pieces, look no further than the designs of Jennifer Fisher. You can find some personalized pieces on here as well, but be aware, they can creep up into the higher price range.

EDIT: Upon completing this post, I discovered an additional 19 quality affordable online jewelry stores that I think you’ll love! I’ve quickly listed their links below if you need more inspiration and gift ideas.

Luv AJ
Bing Bang NYC
Wolf Circus
EF Collection
Sophie Ratner
SHW (Still House)
Kinn
Tarin Thomas
F + H
Minette
Rose Gypsy
Soko
Wilhelmina Garcia
Arlo
Pamela Love – Curating your ear stack? Check out the selection on this site!
Opale-Bijoux
Amarilo
Girls Crew – Super girly, flirty, and fun, done in an elevated way!
Little Rooms

The Top 26 Online Jewelry Stores With The Best Quality And Surprisingly Affordable Prices